Critique is defined by the Oxford Dictionary as a detailed analysis and assessment of something and in 2010 Judith Tyner released the book Principles of Map Design and included the diagram on the right, defining the map making process.
Map critique plays an important role in the design process and this is for a number of reasons:
- Feedback will improve your map – If you always think you’re right, how do you know for sure your map is actually any good and doing what it is intended?
- It allows you to analyse the way you work – Constructive criticism can lead you away from bad practices and towards good ones. Mistakes can be spotted and you can learn from them.
- It can give you an advantage – Criticism can be information that perhaps no one else has, making your map a better one. This is valuable information and give you an edge amongst your competitors.